Kenwyne Jones: Is he a Cole or a Drogba?
Wednesday, January 21, 2009 at 9:32AM
Palacios has completed his medical, all down to personal terms being agreed now. Would be nice that some day Spurs will have a scouting network that allows them to pick up these players BEFORE they become flavour of the month with other clubs who got there first. An obvious change in mentality is needed. Just because we are a rich club that can attract players to London life doesn’t mean we need to be lazy with our approach and wait for other clubs to pluck players from obscurity, and then wait for us to come in with an over-inflated bid. Well done to Wigan for purchasing a reserve player for less than a million and selling him for fourteen. Now that's sell-on value that Levy would appreciate.
Still no confirmation on Appiah, but the forum and message board 'In The Know' peeps are suggesting it's still going to happen. We shall see.
We have also apparently signed Chelsea keeper Cudicini for a million. Great if he is at the club to give Gomes competition and play as number 2. Not so great if ‘arry has decided to sell Gomes. My money is on Carlo being a replacement for Sanchez. If this is confirmed later on, then good work on getting experienced Premiership cover for this position.
Our interest in Kenwyne Jones seems to have gone quiet due to Sunderland’s insistence that he will not be sold under any circumstances. Two schools of thought about this player, so if you are either Spurs or Sunderland I wouldn’t mind hearing your opinions on him. To be honest, I’ve not seen enough of the guy in action. And Match of the Day highlights when he does play well is not a good basis for making a true educated opinion on his value.
School of Thought #1 ‘He’s a Carlton Cole’
Not that Cole is a bad player to have at the minute (evident by his recent form for the Hammers). Cole’s got rid of the dj’ing and other distractions (and his knees seems to be ok nowadays) and also has the comfort of no competition at West Ham which has actually worked positively in his favour. So is Jones just a clone of Carlton? Jones is not prolific. He is not a natural goal-scorer and arguably has a poor touch and finishing ability compared to other Prem forwards (let alone players actually worth '£15M'). He’s also a bit lazy and apart from being a bit of a lump the only quality he does have is he’s good in the air.
School of Thought #2 ‘He’s a young Drogba’
I’m sure this has stuck from the time Roy Keane said he was the best forward in the country and he wouldn’t sell him for £20M. It was Keane who compared him to Drogba, and others also believe he will develop into the same type of player and that currently he is simply a young version of the Chelsea striker (without the diving). Simply needs to mature as a player before the class shines through. Can you see it? I can’t. Maybe I’m not looking hard enough.
The only question that should be asked (if this deal was to get back on track)? Is he what we need? I’d say what we need at the moment is a foil for Defoe. I don’t have faith in Bent and I think Pav would also probably benefit from a foilesque type of player.
Both JD and Pav are potentially 15-20 goals per season players, if partnered up well (whether that’s together is something Harry needs to work out). So, Jones – or whoever we look at as an alternative – is going to be our 3rd option. And that would have to be a bit of a lump with a touch of pace. Would also be a bonus if he had a good touch and finishing abilities.
Jones is big and can put himself about. And he has pace. And he also fits the Redknapp seal of approval. He’s the type of player he goes for. Obviously, considering we have enquired/bid for him. We also need someone who is strong in the air, and there’s no doubting this particular trait of Jones.
So is he the right forward to help complete the required trinity for survival and progression? Goals have dried up at the Lane since Berba and Keano moved on.
Regardless of whether he is closer to Cole than he is to Drogba (I still don't see it) or somewhere in the middle of the two.
Would you swap him for Bent? Would Sunderland be silly enough to take Bent?
With us being far from safe in our Prem League standing, does Jones fit the bill with the task at hand? If he doesn’t, who does?
Reader Comments (9)
Forgot to mention, we are in for Inter's Burdisso. Hard-nut who looks to get sent off.
Yay.
Palacios is official!
We are delighted to announce that we have reached agreement for the transfer of Wilson Palacios from Wigan Athletic.
Personal terms have been agreed and a medical completed, we now await the Honduran international receiving his work permit before completing his registration.
The midfielder made 41 appearances for the Latics after joining in January, 2008 having started the 2007/08 campaign on loan with Birmingham City, where he featured on eight occasions.
The 24-year-old had previously played for Honduran top-flight side Olimpia where he scored 32 goals in 102 appearances.
I'm uncertain about Jones in the same way that I don't think much of Cole. Just don't think he is worth anywhere near £15M. Bent isn't worth £16M and we paid that so I don't blame Sunderland trying to get us much as possible but you could argue Bent has been proven in the Prem in the past and has even played for England. For £8M, I wouldnt complain about it.
He's ok. Not exceptional but does a job well for Sunderland and will probably do one for us, if we signed him. Which I don't think we will.
I'm a bit miffed now that with no DoF, we are going to buy players that will not really push as back to the level of Everton and Villa and possibly City (if they get their act together).
Would you have been happy with Jones had he been linked in the summer?
I guess we should expect this type of quality from Redknapp.
Personally I think Jones is a good player and when he was bought by Keane there were a lot of raised eyebrows. But he performed well and indeed John Terry did say he was the hardest forward to defend against that season. Managers tend to see things in players that us fans simply dont. In the system Harry is trying to employ Jones has all the attributes to get the best out of Defoe. The deal wont happen now but perhaps in the summer when Sunderland have more time to find a replacement I reckon a bid of £10m would be enough to get him even if that is a little over priced.
Reckon Heskey is probably a closer comparison, not a great goal scorer but can hold the ball up and mix it with the likes of John Terry. In other words a welcome addition to our forward line and a straight swap for Bent would be good business.
Unfortunately any striker we sign suffers from being compared to the holy trinity of Berb, Keane and Defoe (witness the lampooning out top scorer is subjected to). Oh, and he wont have Steed "9 Assists" Malbranque putting it on a plate for him.
Yeah, Heskey is more of what Jones is all about. And we were linked to Heskey a while back.
I think us Spurs fans get blinded by the glam signings and can't see past these type of necessity additions to the squad.
Do we want Defoe to score loads of goals? Yes? Then we need a Jones style player.
I'm with Harry on this one.
Jones is far better than Cole but with him I can just see Modric standing there watching the ball fly over his head all the time.
I would prefer a fit Dean Ashton but that looks unlikely.What a horrible performance last night. 11 guys playing as individuals. Get the ball, kick and hope.